Classifieds Questions

Since this is the place to make suggestions for improvements to the site, I'm posting this here. However most of the time, I find that many suggestions fall on deaf ears when submitted directly instead of in a forum. This is not a rant but legitimate questions about the classifieds:


1. Will the classifieds be broken into sections like the old site? (Separate pages: For sale, Wanted, Free to a good home) Those features really made it easy to look for items on the old site.

2. When someone "commits to buy", the ad disappears and it is no longer available, not even for editing or reposting. Anyone can click on that button but it doesn't force them to follow through on the transaction. It's a problem when someone has multiple items of the same thing for sale and it creates down time for the seller.

3. Another feature on the old site was the location listed for the item. It was on the main page with the list of items. It was super easy to look for things that were local.

4. I see a comment saying that if some of the features are not showing up, then I can subscribe to a premier account. Is there such a thing? Is there a cost?


.

Mike_Pop said:

Since this is the place to make suggestions for improvements to the site, I'm posting this here. However most of the time, I find that many suggestions fall on deaf ears when submitted directly instead of in a forum. This is not a rant but legitimate questions about the classifieds:

Click to expand...

I have never not answered a direct question you asked me, so I dont know how it falls on deaf ears.....


Let me start by saying I have not done anything with the classifieds other than basic setup right now. I brought them up and made them functional. There is a lot of tweaks and adjustments that need to be done, but minor 'layout' issues aside, its every bit as functional as before. I have set it aside in lieu of other parts that are not functional at all yet, such as the member map, the new TM section etc.

Mike_Pop said:

1. Will the classifieds be broken into sections like the old site? (Separate pages: For sale, Wanted, Free to a good home) Those features really made it easy to look for items on the old site.

Click to expand...

I am actually slightly confused on this, as it specifically asks you when you set up an ad if its 'for sale' or 'wanted'. It doesnt seem to do anything with the information! It 'might' be the difference of having the 'commit to buy' button available or not. As obviously, you cant buy a wanted item.

Mike_Pop said:

2. When someone "commits to buy", the ad disappears and it is no longer available, not even for editing or reposting. Anyone can click on that button but it doesn't force them to follow through on the transaction. It's a problem when someone has multiple items of the same thing for sale and it creates down time for the seller.

Click to expand...

I am aware there are some glitches with the commit to buy system. I intend to work them out when I can. As for the multiple items... I dont really intend to put a large deal of effort into that. People selling large qty of the same thing are usually more 'business' oriented, and thats not the goal of the classifieds.

Mike_Pop said:

3. Another feature on the old site was the location listed for the item. It was on the main page with the list of items. It was super easy to look for things that were local.

Click to expand...

see note above....

Mike_Pop said:

4. I see a comment saying that if some of the features are not showing up, then I can subscribe to a premier account. Is there such a thing? Is there a cost?

Click to expand...

As of right now there is no 'premier' account for the classified section.

I have never not answered a direct question you asked me, so I dont know how it falls on deaf ears.....

Click to expand...

Definitely up for debate. You asked for site suggestions and I am providing them. This is the first real response I've ever gotten instead of a blown head gasket.

I am actually slightly confused on this, as it specifically asks you when you set up an ad if its 'for sale' or 'wanted'. It doesnt seem to do anything with the information! It 'might' be the difference of having the 'commit to buy' button available or not. As obviously, you cant buy a wanted item.

Click to expand...

Not much to be confused about. Compare the old classified main page site with the new. Although when submitting an ad, the radio buttons ask what type of ad it is, while viewing the classifieds main page, ads are not broken down like the old site. See this page on the old site: http://old.steelsoldiers.com/index.php?name=PN_zClassifieds

Also, while on the main classified page, only the most recent ads are shown without any additional pages. You have to actually click on the "active ads" link. Some people may not see that and think that only the most recent ads are the only ones available.

I am aware there are some glitches with the commit to buy system. I intend to work them out when I can. As for the multiple items... I dont really intend to put a large deal of effort into that. People selling large qty of the same thing are usually more 'business' oriented, and thats not the goal of the classifieds.

Click to expand...

Regardless of the quantity, if someone uses the "commit to buy" button, the ad disappears completely and there is no way to reinsert it without rewriting the ad all together. I'm discouraged to post multiple items for sale because of having to constantly resubmit my ads.

see note above....

Click to expand...

See old site classified page where the location is listed, making it easy to find local items. http://old.steelsoldiers.com/modules.php?op=modload&name=PN_zClassifieds&file=index&cat=1

As of right now there is no 'premier' account for the classified section.

Click to expand...

Will there be in the future? If not, why the confusion now?


One other question...
Was the design of the new site made from scratch or from some sort of template? If it is a template, I can understand why there are many features that seem uneccessary. Keeping the members informed and updated would be a HUGE help.

Listening to suggestions is NOT the same as DOING as suggested, and it probably shouldn't be - some grumpy old men like me would suggest some things that would destroy the site in short order probably.

As to one point you raised, you are mistaken - and I was too at first until I looked a little closer. Relisting a "sold" item absolutely couldn't be easier.

When an item sells you get an email from the site that contains a URL to the now hidden "sold" ad. In that email is the URL to the ad. There is a tab at the bottom of the ad that says "list an identical item". Paste the link into your browser, click the "sell
an identical item" tab, and your ad is back alive. If you want to make changes, use the edit button.

HTH,
David

David,

Thanks for the suggestion. I did not see the link in the email sent to me nor was the link visible at the time my ad was ended. Upon further research, I do see the "submit a similar item" link.

I've found that many features on this site have to be hunted for. The time it takes to find links compared to the old site is much longer and that's not because of it being a different site. It's because the old site didn't have as much going on.

What about this page?



click 'your profile' and it brings this page up, you can toggle through your different types of listings.

Ok...2 out of 4 questions resolved.

Mike_Pop said:

Ok...2 out of 4 questions resolved.

Click to expand...

Mike,

What are the two that aren't?

Perhaps I can help.

DD

If I may throw in my 2 cents,

As stated earlier in this thread, it is difficult to find local ads. It would be great if the classified ads would show in the title where the items are located. I'm looking to buy a deuce and check the classifieds daily. It's a pain to have to click each vehicle's listing to find out where a vehicle is located. I won't even consider purchasing a truck on the east coast since shipping that distance is not a viable option. Browsing the for sale section would be much easier if I knew where the vehicle is located before I ever click on the ad.

Jinx,

I asked that question above but apparantly, it's too confusing for the programmer of this site.

The old site had categories of items for sale, wanted, and free to a good home. The old site also had the location listed on the title of the ad. My guess is that it makes too much sense to keep things the same and make it easy for the users.

While I do/did like that feature ALOT, I think the problem lies more in the format of the new site.

Mike_Pop
4 Star General
Mike_Pop's Profile Fields



Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: 39°30'47.75"N 115°57'43.58"W
Posts: 1,116





"I asked that question above but apparantly, it's too confusing for the programmer of this site. "

"The old site also had the location listed "


So Mike how would you think a location should be listed, So as not to be confusing?


" Location: 39°30'47.75"N 115°57'43.58"W "


But I do agree.. Location, Buy, Sell, Trade.. price and item should be in Title.
J.P.

POOF:

Look up the classifieds on the old site.